America’s housing market has a strange imbalance: homes keep coming up for sale while buyers are disappearing. In Redfin’s September estimate, there were about 1.51 million sellers and 929,000 buyers. Sellers outnumbered buyers by 62.6%, a gap of roughly 582,000. That is the widest imbalance in Redfin’s data going back to 2013.
September 2026 estimate of active home sellers and buyers in the US.
The main brake, put plainly, is that homes have become too expensive for too many people. Redfin points to high housing costs and mortgage rates: the monthly payment can turn an ordinary home into a luxury purchase. Would-be buyers postpone a deal or leave the market altogether, while listings continue to pile up. September brought the lowest estimated buyer count in the series and the most sellers since March 2020.
Still, this is not a story of every homeowner rushing for the exit. People list for different reasons:
The shift is visible across the country. Of the 50 largest US metro areas, 41 were buyer’s markets, five remained seller’s markets, and four were balanced, according to Redfin.
Balance of buyers and sellers across the 50 largest US metro areas.
In short: sellers are plentiful because listings keep arriving; buyers are scarce because the entry price has become prohibitive. Is this a real shift in negotiating power, or just a pause until prices and incomes finally meet?
September 2026 estimate of active home sellers and buyers in the US.
The main brake, put plainly, is that homes have become too expensive for too many people. Redfin points to high housing costs and mortgage rates: the monthly payment can turn an ordinary home into a luxury purchase. Would-be buyers postpone a deal or leave the market altogether, while listings continue to pile up. September brought the lowest estimated buyer count in the series and the most sellers since March 2020.
Still, this is not a story of every homeowner rushing for the exit. People list for different reasons:
- Some have stopped waiting for mortgage rates to fall.
- Some are moving for a job or family reasons.
- Some worry prices could soften if they wait longer.
The shift is visible across the country. Of the 50 largest US metro areas, 41 were buyer’s markets, five remained seller’s markets, and four were balanced, according to Redfin.
Balance of buyers and sellers across the 50 largest US metro areas.
Asad Khan, Redfin senior economist“This is a buyer’s market born out of caution, not strength.”
ℹ INFO
For buyers, more choice often means room to negotiate on price, repairs or closing costs. But that leverage helps only people who can still afford the purchase and the mortgage payment.
⚠ IMPORTANT
Redfin compares active listings with an estimated number of buyers. This is not a census of every American household. It measures bargaining power, but does not by itself predict a home-price crash.
In short: sellers are plentiful because listings keep arriving; buyers are scarce because the entry price has become prohibitive. Is this a real shift in negotiating power, or just a pause until prices and incomes finally meet?
Last edited: