The question is simple: if Nasdaq falls noticeably more than the S&P 500, will S&P catch up later? And vice versa - who catches up on the way up? History gives almost the same answer every time: Nasdaq-100 is the S&P 500 on steroids, beta around 1.4. It always moves further in the same direction.
Fig. 1. Crisis years: Nasdaq falls 1.5-2x more. Data: Wikipedia.
Look at the numbers. 2000: -36.8% versus -10.1% for S&P. 2001: -32.7% versus -13.0%. 2002: -37.6% versus -23.4%. Cumulatively over three years Nasdaq lost 73%, S&P about 40%, and there was nobody to catch up - S&P had already fallen less, while Nasdaq took years to recover, only reclaiming its 1999 peak in 2017. 2008: -41.9% versus -38.5% - in the financial crisis the gap was minimal because banks, not just tech, were falling. 2022: -33.0% versus -19.4% - a textbook rate-hike shock that hit long-duration valuations.
Fig. 2. The rebound: Nasdaq reclaims faster. Data: Wikipedia.
Fig. 3. Rallies: Nasdaq accelerates more. Data: Wikipedia.
There is one exception. In 2018 Nasdaq-100 fell only 1.0%, while S&P 500 fell 6.2%. Then banks and the trade war were cut down, not tech, and the broad index lagged.
Fig. 4. The 2018 exception. Data: Wikipedia.
Fig. 1. Crisis years: Nasdaq falls 1.5-2x more. Data: Wikipedia.
Look at the numbers. 2000: -36.8% versus -10.1% for S&P. 2001: -32.7% versus -13.0%. 2002: -37.6% versus -23.4%. Cumulatively over three years Nasdaq lost 73%, S&P about 40%, and there was nobody to catch up - S&P had already fallen less, while Nasdaq took years to recover, only reclaiming its 1999 peak in 2017. 2008: -41.9% versus -38.5% - in the financial crisis the gap was minimal because banks, not just tech, were falling. 2022: -33.0% versus -19.4% - a textbook rate-hike shock that hit long-duration valuations.
What about the rebound
Here the picture reverses. In 2003 Nasdaq jumped 49.1% versus 26.4% for S&P. In 2009: +53.5% versus +23.5%. In 2020: +47.6% versus +16.3%. In 2023 after 2022: +53.8% versus +24.2%. So when the fall is a liquidity panic rather than a broken earnings model, Nasdaq reclaims its losses faster and pulls ahead.Fig. 2. The rebound: Nasdaq reclaims faster. Data: Wikipedia.
What about growth
The same logic on the way up. In 1999, when S&P gained 19.5%, Nasdaq gained 102%. In 2019: 38.0% versus 28.9%. In 2021 and 2024 the gap shrank to 0-1.6 points because mega-caps now sit in both the S&P and Nasdaq-100. But the direction never changes: Nasdaq accelerates harder.Fig. 3. Rallies: Nasdaq accelerates more. Data: Wikipedia.
There is one exception. In 2018 Nasdaq-100 fell only 1.0%, while S&P 500 fell 6.2%. Then banks and the trade war were cut down, not tech, and the broad index lagged.
Fig. 4. The 2018 exception. Data: Wikipedia.
⚠ IMPORTANT
The takeaway: there is no automatic "catch-up". Nasdaq moves in the same direction, but with 1.4-1.7x the amplitude. After a long tech re-rating, as in 2000-2002, the lag lasts for years. After a short panic, as in 2020, Nasdaq pulls ahead of S&P first. Look for the "chase" not in the chart but in the cause of the fall: rates and valuations - S&P is steadier; liquidity and earnings - Nasdaq is more aggressive.